Representing the moderates, iama90210lvr writes, "Really, I love Peyton and would be sad if they killed her but Leyton isn't that couple that goes riding off into the sunset together. It would be more like them for Peyton to die giving childbirth and Lucas go off with the baby. Lucas and Peyton are TRAGIC, that's their thing. You can't tie up every storyline with a pretty little bow."

And for the "let 'em go" faction, NYJOEYBE comes in with a little controversy -- turning "Leyton" to "Pucas"!: "As far as 'Pucas' being dead and gone, I believe it will be addition through subtraction for the show. The focus going to the Scott family of 'Naley' and Jamie, Dan of course, Deb and Brooke should be fantastic!"

Where do you fall in the Lucas and Peyton debate? Head to the message boards and make your case!