Brenda's Secret: Your Theories

Brenda TheoriesBrenda Barrett is BACK on General Hospital and she's got a big secret. But what, pray tell, is it?

 

We asked you to share your theories about what exactly Brenda's secret is, and we pulled them together in gallery form. Click here for YOUR suggestions.

 

Have anymore theories now that Brenda's been on screen for awhile? Share them below!

 

Photo Source: ABC

Comments (32)

Thu, Oct 21 - 12:53 pm

I think that since Ronnie was brought up in Bensinhurst and new Dante way back when. I believe that the cop that Dante looked up to in the neighborhood that he believed was killed by Sonny was not killed by Sonny . That's why Dante spent all those years hating Sonny and wanting to bring him down.I believe either Ronnie did it or knows who did it but fueled the flames of Dante's hate for Sonny by pushing him.Now, remember when Helena demanded to get her painting out of Nicholas' storage. She pulled a birth certificate out of the back. Whose? we don't know. But it must benefit her in some way or she wouldn't have gotten it. What if Franco is a Cassadine? If Brenda had Sonny's baby, i swear i will stop watching GH. I think Brenda is a KOOK and i'm really tired of every man falling all over Brenda. She is attractive, but she is not gods gift to women.

Sat, Sep 11 - 5:35 pm

Brenda is really a Cassadine (and a a real Princess). Because GH is a Soap Opera my crazy theory is the "Sophia" Sonny met in Rome is in fact Sophia Cassadine (she can definitely come back from the dead on a soap). She and her Russian husband were assassinated in 1979 and rumor has it they had a daughter. Brenda would have been 6 years old in 1979. Helena Cassadine was last seen holding a "mysterious" Birth Certificate...hmmm! If Sophia and her Russian husband were in trouble with the Russian Mob that would explain why Brenda is in danger from the same. Brenda has been accused of acting like a "princess" maybe she really is one. I don't know how that would affect Sonny, Carly and Jason though and the rumor mill says they will be the ones most affected by her secret. It would mean she is related to Sam and Kristina but that's about it for impacting the lives of those three. Anyway, true or not I think it would make for a good GH story...

Wed, Aug 18 - 1:13 am

Franco and Brenda are half-siblings. As it turns out the reason Franco snatched Liz and (Lucky's) Nicholas's baby is that Franco is really a Cassadine (which would explain A LOT). Brenda married Alcazar but had Sonny's baby (who by now will be about Christina's age)! A boy called Jake. LOL!

What is this storyline with Brenda and that Brad Pitt wannabe? LOL! Shame.

Tue, Aug 17 - 2:41 am

Brenda's Secret: Your Theories

I'm just happy she's back. Give her a good man and give her a baby. That's all I ask GH... Keep Brenda happy!!!! Finally

Mon, Aug 16 - 10:08 am

I know that the age doesn't match but this is a soap so...what if:
Spinelli is Brenda's son with Jason and Franco is Brenda's half brother (also Spinelli's uncle)? (Brenda's mother had a mental illness so Karen Anderson seems to fit the part!). Franco mentioned that there is a connection with Jason and I don't think that Spinelli has ever seen Brenda's picture. He refers to his room as the "mysterious Brenda's" room. He was raised by his "granny" and lately him and Lulu have talked about how they first met at his granny's house.

Mon, Aug 16 - 8:06 am

Brenda secret ...
She and Franco are married and divorced also they have a son together.

She and Alcazar have been secret been together like Jason never kill him due Brenda have his baby and tell Jason dont kill him. Tell him they will go never ever show up again in Port Charles.

Sun, Aug 15 - 7:44 pm

Why does her secret have to be a baby with one othe GH twits? I am hoping it is something like she is going to help the FBI take down Sonny and Jason. Or perhaps she has been with Lorenzo somewhere lovely. We don't need anymore babies and please, no more children for Sonny!

Sun, Aug 15 - 1:33 pm

@ Tudazwoman: I remember that but I really hope that Franco and Brenda don't have a baby. I rather see Franco and Claire have a baby! that would be very interesting. Claire would have lots of explaining to do.

Sun, Aug 15 - 1:34 pm

Wouldn't it be cool if Franco was really a Quatermaine!! His father could be Alan Quatermaine or maybe even Edward Quatermaine!! Franco could be jealous of Jason like AJ was. I think that Franco's mother should be Brenda's aunt or something, than Franco and Brenda can be cousins.. It would be so interesting to see Franco try to be part of the dysfunctional Quartermaine family! Let me know what everyone thinks. Would you want to see Franco as a Quatermaine! we need more in my opinion.

Sun, Aug 15 - 9:41 am

Is everyone forgetting the Christmas tree lot dialogue between Carly and Franco (selling trees) when she asked, "Do you have kids?" His response, "yes, I do, a little boy...but his mother's a bitch"....

Whatdoyathink? Had to be Brenda....he's a worldwide artist....they travelled in the same circles....She was probably too feisty for him. I'm totally believing she had Franco's child, especially since his last recent scene had him fingering a page of a magazine, saying, "we must get a new model" and it was a page w/Brenda on it. He KNEW her and has definite diabolical plans for Port Charles, and, in particular, Brenda. Can you just imagine their scenes together?!!

You must be a logged in registered user to post a comment.
Already registered with SOAPnet? Login below.
New to SOAPnet? Register Now!